Writing

A Page in the Book

Schnittke’s Infernal Baroque and the Hegelmon

By Ian Jamison · October 8, 2026

An infernal Baroque

In mining stocks there’s a well-worn idea: the junior miners are a leveraged position on gold. When gold goes up, they go up more; when it goes down, they go down harder. The fifth movement of Alfred Schnittke’s Concerto Grosso No. 1 is a leveraged position on the Baroque, and the occasion for what follows.

A concerto grosso pits a small group of soloists against the orchestra. Here the Rondo opens with the two solo violins trading a Vivaldian figure in imitative counterpoint, the imitation so close that it doesn’t much care whether it leaves a dissonance standing. (The tune began life as a song Vladimir Vysotsky sang in a Soviet film.) The opening struck me, and thrilled me, the first time I heard it. Then the tutti arrives and the whole orchestra takes up the figure. The payout is immense: an old idiom, magnified, comes out sounding new and exhilarating. The top comment under a YouTube upload of Gidon Kremer’s recording, as of this writing, puts it more economically: “Corelli on some serious acid.” When leverage fails, all you hear is the risk.

Nothing new, except the dose

Dissonance that won’t resolve is not a modern invention. In 1600 the theorist Giovanni Artusi published On the Imperfections of Modern Music, an attack on this kind of liberty in madrigals by Monteverdi, whom he didn’t name. Monteverdi’s side answered that a new practice, a seconda pratica, was the “perfection of modern music.” The Baroque, in other words, opened with a fight over dissonance, and both sides called the new thing modern.

The fight comes back. In 1887 Chabrier’s opera Le roi malgré lui opened on unresolved sevenths and ninths. Ravel said its premiere changed the course of French harmony, and the young Satie, who heard it that spring, wrote his Sarabandes by September. In 1926 Schoenberg gave the whole tendency a name, “the emancipation of the dissonance.” Adorno, as the musicologist Stephen Hinton notes, traced that emancipation from Wagner all the way back to Monteverdi, and Hinton asks whether Schoenberg’s revolution is the aesthetic cousin of Monteverdi’s. Leo Schrade, for his part, titled his book on Monteverdi Creator of Modern Music. Around 1600 and again around 1900, composers were staking out new aesthetic ground, and both times dissonance was the shovel.

Nor is it new for a modern composer to borrow from the Baroque; there’s no shortage of neo-Baroque. What Schnittke does in this movement is a matter of degree. He takes the tropes of the Baroque and heightens them to a frenzy that’s almost terrifying. An infernal Baroque.

Polystylism, Schnittke’s postmodernism

The piece is postmodern, and polystylism was Schnittke’s own way of getting there. In a 1971 essay he set out its two principles, quotation and allusion, and defined one technique of quotation, adaptation, as “the retelling of an alien musical text in one’s own musical language.” Much postmodern borrowing is what Fredric Jameson called pastiche, a “blank parody” with no conviction behind it. That may be why authenticity feels so rare in the face of postmodernism, and so prized.12 Schnittke’s borrowing doesn’t wink. Introducing the concerto to a Viennese audience in 1977, he wrote that he dreamed of “the utopia of a united style,” in which entertainment and serious music would sit together, and that he used his fragments “absolutely seriously.”

He also thought it was futile. Years later he called that synthesis “pure utopia,” and he did it anyway. Of his Third Symphony he wrote, “I attempt to compose symphonies, although it is clear to me that logically it is pointless.” Steve Reich felt something similar. When the flutist Ransom Wilson asked him to write a flute concerto, Reich, opposed to the form, turned him down, then wrote him Vermont Counterpoint, what one scholar calls a “concerto for one.” Schnittke kept writing the old forms while doubting them; Reich went around them.

So the fifth movement is a Baroque body, worked over with a modernist tool, inside a postmodern frame. Magnifying the Baroque is one path into the postmodern question.

The book of Art History

People working in the high arts (composers, painters, playwrights) are partly trying to become the next page in their art’s history. Harold Bloom called the strain of it, the struggle with the precursors you have to get past, the anxiety of influence. The sociologist Pierre Bourdieu described the field it happens in: a field of restricted production, where the currency is prestige and consecration and the audience is largely other producers, set against a field of large-scale production, where the currency is the market. Classical music lives in the first.

There are several ways to try for the page. You can jump ahead, as Schoenberg did when he followed chromaticism to its farthest horizon, or Boulez when he serialized not just pitch but duration and dynamics. Both were obeying what Adorno called the historical tendency of the musical material. You can react, as Reich and Glass did, leaning into exactly what serialism denied, tonality and steady repeated rhythm. You can go by negation, as Cage did, a composer above all because he thought hard about composing. Or you can synthesize, as John Adams does, building with minimalism’s blocks a structure with the motion and arch of a Beethoven sonata. Schnittke widened the tradition downward,3 an omnivore with his feet planted on the traditional path.

What they share is that each of them is vying for the next page.

The Hegelmon

Hegel imagined history as one spirit, Geist, moving in a single necessary direction. I want a word that nods to Hegel and hegemony at once:4 a dominant direction of travel inside what William James called a pluralistic universe. Call it the Hegelmon. It has preeminence, not supremacy.

Commercial music answers to the market, and every genre serves its niche. Classical music answers to something else, the prestige and consecration of Bourdieu’s restricted field, and these make up one of the Hegelmon’s pillars. Think of the old orders: priests, warriors, farmers, merchants. The high arts sit with the priests; Nietzsche saw them taking the seat as “creeds relax.”5 The merchants’ currency has been gaining ground for a long time; think of homo economicus.6

But the priestly pillar still stands, and not as decoration: it bears weight. You can feel it in ordinary life. Tell a mechanic, a pop musician, a senator, a teacher or a barista that you’re a composer, and something like respect comes back, as if you’d said you were a working wizard. They don’t know whether your music is any good, and most of them have no appetite for new classical music. The respect isn’t for the music. It’s for the office. The high arts are part of the framing a culture stands on, the way timber frames a house or steel holds up a skyscraper, and that is classical music’s special bind to the Hegelmon.

Schnittke stood on that pillar, but he ranged all over the Hegelmon’s course, and sometimes off it, into tangos, nursery tunes and the music of his own film scores (more than sixty of them). What he wanted was to consecrate the knickknacks: to carry them up onto the priestly pillar.

Close

Jean-François Lyotard defined the postmodern, “simplifying to the extreme,” as “incredulity toward metanarratives.” Read one way, that announces there’s no legitimate trunk left on the tree, that legitimacy can only be approached from the branches, if at all. Schnittke’s polystylism is a postmodern answer, but he gives it in a decidedly traditional vessel, the concerto grosso, and in doing so he tacitly anchors himself to the trunk and confers legitimacy on it, as every high artist does. What matters isn’t the medium. It’s whether you’re vying for a page in the book, the holy book that consecration writes and the high arts stand on.

Notes

  1. The longing runs through the high arts. In 1993, in “E Unibus Pluram,” David Foster Wallace imagined the next literary rebels as “anti-rebels,” writers who would “dare somehow to back away from ironic watching” and treat “old untrendy human troubles” with “reverence and conviction.”↩
  2. Even commerce has noticed. In 2007 James H. Gilmore and B. Joseph Pine II published Authenticity: What Consumers Really Want (Harvard Business School Press), arguing that “consumers choose to buy or not buy based on how real they perceive an offering to be.” In 2023 Merriam-Webster named “authentic” its word of the year, and the market researchers at Ipsos went on to survey what Americans take an “authentic” brand to be.↩
  3. Downward in the old sense of high and low, the sense in which the high arts are “high.”↩
  4. Antonio Gramsci’s “cultural hegemony,” a dominance won and held by consent, could cover much of what I mean, but it names a dominance, not a direction.↩
  5. “Art raises its head where creeds relax,” Nietzsche wrote in Human, All Too Human (1878); it takes over “many feelings and moods engendered by religion.”↩
  6. Thomas Carlyle was already warning in Past and Present (1843) that “Cash-payment is not the sole relation of human beings,” and that “Mammon-worship is a melancholy creed.”↩
All writing
WordPress Appliance - Powered by TurnKey Linux